How Training to Failure is Ruining Your Gains

November 13, 2019

By: Jared Blincow CSCS, FRC, Coach at LIFT Chicago

How many times have you heard that if you’re leaving reps on the table and not training to failure then you’re missing out on some serious gains? What if I told you there was an alternative approach that was just as effective, allowed for greater recovery, higher quality reps, and still yielded the same results?

I’m not saying there isn’t a time and place where training to failure fits into a well-designed program (I’ve been known to rep out bicep curls until I can’t lift my arms the next every now and then) but if you’re consistently taking every single exercise you do to failure day in and day out then it might be time to reconsider your training habits. Here’s a few reasons why training to failure isn’t always the optimal option:

  • Training to failure has a much higher metabolic fatiguing effect than sub-maximal training (duh). If you’re taking your very first set to failure this will impact every other set you do that training session. Instead of being able to hit three consistent sets of 135 for 8 on bench press, you might only be able to go 135 for 10, 135 for 7, and 135 for 5, ultimately ending up with a lower total workload than if you left 1 or 2 reps in the tank for each set. 

  • Training to failure too often won’t allow your body to fully recover between training sessions. There’s a time and place to push the limits in the weight room, but if you are doing it every training session for weeks at a time you’re hurting you progress. You’re not allowing your body to fully recover for the next training session and potentially setting yourself up for injury or over training. 

  • Training to muscle failure and training to technical failure are two different things. Typically, when training to muscular failure the last few reps are “cheated” reps done with poor form and could potentially do more harm than good. Training to technical failure still forces us to work hard and push ourselves but keeps a few reps in reserve. This ensures we are moving efficiently and using the actual parts of the body we are trying to recruit. Taking a set of bicep curls to muscular fatigue and using a little body english to finish out the last few reps isn’t the worst thing in the world, but pushing a compound movement like the squat to absolute failure could be especially detrimental and put the body in a compromising position to squeak out those last couple reps.

  • Trained lifters who train consistently are able to recruit muscle groups more efficiently and don’t necessarily need to train to absolute failure in order to optimally fatigue the muscles. One adaptation of consistent weight training is an increase in neuromuscular coordination and greater motor unit control, creating greater muscle tension earlier in sets. 

  • Just because you aren’t training to failure doesn’t mean you aren’t working hard. I’m not saying that doing sets of 3 with a weight you can lift 15 times will get it done in the gym. However, progressively overloading movements, allowing time to recover between sessions, picking your times to push the envelope and training consistently will provide greater results than just picking up a weight and cranking out as many reps as you can do with poor form until you can’t lift your arms the next day. Quality reps and training sessions with sound programming will always outperform quantity.  

What People Are Saying About Lift Chicago

  • I’ve been training at Lift since it opened (and with Josh elsewhere for a few years prior). As a middle aged endurance athlete, I used to think I should strength... read more

    thumb Dana Rothschild

    I’ve been training at LIFT for 1.5 years. Each and every one of the trainers are knowledgeable, friendly, professional, and extremely efficient. It’s surprising how great of a workout you... read more

    thumb Kendra Chavin

    I started attending the women’s lifting class and absolutely love it! It’s exciting, fun and welcoming for all different ability levels!

    thumb Lainie Augensen
  • Hands down best gym for power lifters, strong men, body builders. Equipment is top notch and it’s very clean and well maintained.

    thumb Katie Cunningham

    I’ve had such a great experience here, especially training with Coach Abby! The trainers here are very attentive and helpful, which I definitely appreciate since I’m pretty new to weight... read more

    thumb Linda Quizhpi

    I have trained with the guys at Lift for a long time and consider my sessions to be some of my best long-term investments. My workouts there are sustainable, enjoyable... read more

    thumb Brigid Sweeney
  • Can’t recommend LIFT enough. If you’re looking for challenging, yet functional, strength training program to look and feel your best, LIFT is the place. All of the coaches there are... read more

    thumb Samantha Allen

    After working out at LIFT for a year now, I can't say enough good things about this place. My trainer, Isaac, is kind, knowledgeable, experienced, and careful, making sure... read more

    thumb Paula Hoste

    Lift Chicago is a fantastic full-service gym. The trainers are knowledgable and motivating, the facility is clean and bright, and they take all steps to insure health and safety. As... read more

    thumb Margaret Berg
  • I've been working with Abby 3 days a week since October 2021, and it's probably not too much of a stretch to say I'm in love with her. In... read more

    thumb Ryan Carter

    I have trained with the guys at Lift for a long time and consider my sessions to be some of my best long-term investments. My workouts there are sustainable, enjoyable... read more

    thumb Brigid Sweeney

    I have a very busy schedule, so my training sessions need to be very efficient, staying under an hour at all times. LIFT provides a highly “efficient” workout protocol—... read more

    thumb Pete Wilkins
  • Positive: Communication ,  Professionalism ,  Quality

    thumb The Wheelands

    I've been training at LIFT since they opened and the trainers here are second to none. They are highly skilled, consummate professionals, and just all around nice guys. ... read more

    thumb Chris Jamerson

    It has been challenging for me to find the motivation to workout since the beginning of the pandemic. Lift has helped me to get back into a routine in a... read more

    thumb Stephanie Garcia
  • Positive: Professionalism ,  Quality I started attending the women’s lifting class and absolutely love it! It’s exciting, fun and welcoming for all different ability levels!

    thumb Lainie Augensen

    I recently found Lift on Yelp like a month ago and I’m absolutely loving it. I workout with Sam, Isaac and Kyle and they’re amazing. I’m looking forward to continuing... read more

    thumb Mandy Jo Walker

    Great coaching in an excellent facility.

    thumb Rick Sudekum
  • WOW!!! I cannot say enough great things about Lift Chicago! Truly a fantastic experience. First off, with all things COVID, I felt very safe and comfortable using the equipment. Every... read more

    thumb Alexis Jawny

    I’ve been training at Lift since it opened, and with Pete prior to. Everyone here is always extremely professional and so very nice. They may not know it, but they... read more

    thumb Jenny Gariepy

    I have always been a very active person but I have seen the biggest difference in both my strength and physique since working out at Lift. I’ve been to many... read more

    thumb Alison
  • I started training at LIFT over a year ago in prep for my wedding. I have never looked or felt better! I have worked with almost every coach, and they’re... read more

    thumb Cara j

    These deserve more stars. Ive been rocking with these guys for years. Always fun and professional. They have help me achieve my body goals by coming 3 days a... read more

    thumb Domique Bland

    Great workout for busy professionals. Simply the best !

    thumb Chris Santiago